One of the female candidates who contested the January 18, 2023, general
elections on behalf of the opposition United Progressive Party, Dr. Cleon Athill,
has tendered her resignation from the party.
In her letter of resignation, Dr. Athill cites ‘Problematic leadership style’ and the
absence of a ‘well-defined and articulated political philosophy’ as among the
reasons for her departure from the political party.
General Secretary of the UPP, Sen. Shawn Nicholas, informed the party faithful by
letter telling them of Dr. Athill’s resignation. She provided no reasons for Dr.
Athill’s departure.
The letter from GS, Sen. Nicholas is published below followed by the letter from
Dr. Athill.
Resignation of Cleon Athill
Brothers and Sisters,
Please note that Sis. Cleon Athill has tendered her resignation from the Party.
We take this opportunity to thank her for her contribution to the Party and offer
our best wishes.
Regards,
Sis. Shawn M Nicholas
General Secretary
Shawn Nicholas
General Secretary
United Progressive Party
February 22, 2024
Dear Madam:
Greetings. Trust that you are in the best of health and spirits.
It is with much sadness that I pen this advisory and even sadder that I am
moved to a position to pen it.
About three years ago after much deliberation, and at the chilling exhortation of
my eldest son, Tijani to be the change I wished to see, I answered the call to
enter into electoral politics. I was excited to be part of the UPP’s slate heading
into the upcoming General election. I understood it as a call for me to make a
difference, and I accepted it with a strong resolve and welcomed the UPP as the
platform/machinery for that to happen.
I quickly set about the business of the campaign: gathered my team, did a
SWOT analysis, defined campaign ethos, and developed and articulated the
campaign strategic plan. Team Athill went about its business strategically. Its
approach, the community engagement community empowerment approach,
behooved us to adopt a new campaign style, aimed at bringing the community
together instead of dividing it. I can say without any fear of contradiction that
we did manage to move the constituents beyond what was expected. The
outcome of the election bore testimony to this.
The road though has not been an easy one. This is because I chose to engage in
the political space differently and endeavoured to run a positive campaign.
Over the course of the campaign, I heard that I had a different style, and it
quickly became obvious that this so-called different style found no favour with
the leadership of the party nor with the campaign management team. The party
leadership
would be in a better position to elucidate its position and actions regarding
this.
It is also apparent that this “style” continues to be an issue, and it will continue
to be an issue because it reflects the essence of who I am, an epitome of my
philosophy and theory of change, Further, this style appears to be antithetical to
the UPP ethos. Consequently, the past three years of my association with the
UPP and my involvement in the campaign have presented my most serious
existential dilemma/challenge. It has caused me to question myself, politics, our
political maturity, opposition ideology and mentality, partisan and tribal culture
and so on…and I’ve seen how much of the game we play for politics
undermines/ thwarts the forward movement of our beloved country. I know
we can do better. We can be better. Antigua and Barbuda deserves better.
With that said, I write to advise that I resign my position as caretaker and my
association with the United Progressive Party.
I continue to be a champion for the changes that we talk about for the
development of Antigua and Barbuda and for St Paul.
I wish to thank all those who believed in me, encouraged me, prayed for me,
and journeyed with me over those last three years. They’ve provided a
sounding board for sharing perspectives, and they’ve provided shoulders to lean
and cry on. Thanks for helping me to know that a new way is indeed possible
and strengthening my resolve to pursue it.
I believe in the collective power of our people to transcend the uncertainties of
now. I believe in St Paul and its expressed desire to be better. And I continue
to celebrate their expressed declaration that they are “no ordinary
constituency”.
Finally, I wish to thank the UPP for the opportunity to serve the way I did over
the last three years. I wish however to highlight a few observations and urge
the party to pay urgent attention to them if it is to stand out from among the
pile of “all ah dem ah de same”
1. Problematic leadership style and organizational culture: Leadership
style and structure to reflect a more democratic and transformational
approach
2. Poor support to branches: The support given to capacity building,
particularly at the branch level
3. Divisive primaries: Revisit its position and practice viz a viz primaries
as a way of choosing candidates. These tend to be divisive and
disruptive.
4. Opposition mentality: Rethink its role and function as opposition
5. Lack of philosophical grounding: A well-defined and articulated political
philosophy and change theory that aligns with what is in the best
interest of Antigua and Barbuda
All the very best to you as you continue to fine-tune the party for and in the
interest of Antigua and Barbuda.
Respectfully
Cleon Athill
Cleon Athill, Ph.D.
Cc: Clarissa Christopher
Chair, St Paul UPP Branch
